Archive for February, 2009

Mutual Fund Perils

Friday, February 13th, 2009

The primary principle underlying the formation of the mutual funds was that a single person could focus and handle the investments of huge amount of money from various investors. In the old days, prior to great depression mutual funds were also known as investment pools and mutual fund managers were known as pool operators. The bull market of 20s produced the economic boom that was similar to the situation of 90s. It was at this time the idea of the pyramid scheme first conceived.

The pyramid scheme was discredited in 1920 with the arrest of Charles Ponzi for giving untenable returns on postal certificates. This caused massive losses to the investors who fell for the Ponzi’s well-planned fraudulent job and his name got associated with this type of jobs. He earned massive profits by purchasing the postal certificates in Europe at reduced price and then selling them for high price in the US. Sadly, people never considered the idea of the investment pool as the latest type of Ponzi scheme.

Investment pools were finally considered by people as a type of fraud. This is because a pool operator had the authority to rob the people. Instead of protecting the interests of the investors, the pool operators indulged in risky investments since they did not own the money. Their fees were quite high. So when the stock market crashed in 1929, the people understood that investment pools were a big scam perpetuated on the unsuspecting public.

The pool managers misused the system to such an extent that ultimately the Security Exchange Commission (SEC) was formed mainly to check these conmen. The SEC managed to close down the more obvious scams. This made the securities industry change tacks and they introduced the investment pools as mutual funds to lure gullible public back in their grip.

Try to stash away your money in an indexed mutual fund if your 401(k) provider allows it. An indexed mutual fund tracks a stock market index like the S&P500 to inform you about the stocks purchased. The Vanguard 500 (VFINX) is the largest and oldest indexed mutual fund.

The cash held by the fund is divided to try to track the index to the closest possible degree. Also there is no fund manager involved in the fund to rob you of your retirement savings under the guise of fees.

MUTUAL FUNDS AND TAX TRAP

Friday, February 13th, 2009

The non-indexed mutual funds make you lose money by making you pay taxes. You might be liable to pay taxes though your mutual fund makes a loss. However for many people this is highly unforeseen event. This is how this contradictory event takes place. Legally, mutual funds do not have to pay taxes. Instead they pass on these taxes to the shareholders of the mutual fund, which means you are forced to pay the taxes.

If the fund manager sells the stock at a price higher than its cost, the fund makes the profit. This profit is known as a capital gain and is taxed. Capital gains carry the regular income tax rate of 28%-38.6% for the investors holding the stock below the year. For the investors holding the stock for over a year or long term, the tax rate is 20%.

There are some reasons why mutual funds have to pay taxes. If the fund performance is poor, investors tend to leave. The mutual fund is forced to sell stock to pay the leaving investors. Though you may not be one of the investors wanting to leave, you will still be taxed your share of the capital gains tax.

The other reason for paying taxes is the dividends paid. Dividends are taxed as per share income distributions that companies make from their quarterly earnings. Many investors choose to automatically reinvest their dividends. This provides the fund with the money to purchase more shares for you. So if you reinvest and yet do not take out a single cent from the dividends, they are still taxed as per the IRS rules.

The other reason for paying tax is the high turnover. Turnover is the rate at which a fund manager purchases and sells shares, at times to avail of the next winning stock or undervalued stock that is about to shoot up. The average funds in 2000 had a turnover rate of 122%. It implied that the whole portfolio between January and December had changed and about 22% of the replacement shares too changed.

It is the extreme case of account churning. You should remember that when you are purchasing a fund you are taking on the tax liability. The excellent method of not paying these taxes is to limit your purchases of mutual funds to your 401(k) and just buy indexed mutual funds.